uRBAN WAREHOUSING ACCORDING TO AMAZON

Amazon is a dominant player in the e-commerce sector, accounting for 38% of the total e-commerce market in the US in 2022. Although facing criticism for its impact on small businesses, the environment, and labor practices, Amazon is leading the way in innovative distribution practices, such as urban logistics centers and vertical integration, establishing itself as a pioneer in the industry.

Last update on April 19th, 2023 by Camille Horvath

In 2021, for the United States, the logistic footprint of Amazon represents 302.6 million square feet of logistics equipment and warehouses, or 28.1 million square meters, and more than 144.6 million square feet of projects, or 13.4 million square meters planned (2021-2024).

Logistics footprint and average size of Amazon logistics facilities, mid 2020 (Rodrigue, 2020).

Amazon dominates the e-commerce market, while also being the second-largest market player in retail behind Walmart. Their vertical integration and efficient supply chain management have resulted in significant revenue and sales growth, aided by the Covid-19 pandemic. Amazon's logistics system is organized around interlocking warehouses, logistics equipment, and proprietary transport services, including a fleet of cargo planes. The company is shifting its strategy towards direct ownership and control of most aspects of the supply chain, reducing its dependence on third-party providers and achieving a shorter click-to-door time than the industry average. Amazon warehouses are listed from 9 warehouse categories.

Fulfillment and Distribution Centers are large centers that handle online orders and can range from 500 000 to 2 million square feet in size. Many of these centers are being partially or fully automated and expanded, both within the existing building and outside. The centers can also be specialized by product type or handling and packaging, such as "small sortable" for small products under 10 kilos, "large sortable" for bigger products between 10 and 25 kilos, or "large non-sortable" for heavy or bulky items like furniture or TVs. As of September 2021, there are currently 264 facilities and 106 projects in progress. Amazon's distribution centers are the largest part of its spatial footprint, covering 184.8 million square feet (17.1 million m²), or nearly 61% of its total warehouse space. Distribution centers also account for 49.4% of the total planned space.

Amazon has two types of small last-mile delivery centers called Delivery Stations (Packages) and Delivery Stations (Heavy/Bulky). These facilities serve as distribution locations for delivery drivers picking up packages or as final delivery locations for orders not intended for home delivery. They are the most represented type of warehouse, with 454 of them dispersed across the country and another 275 projects in 2021.They are the most local link in Amazon's logistics system and there are many in urban and suburban areas for third-party carriers, Amazon delivery agents and customers. Some of these locations also serve as pick-up points, including Amazon locker banks. Delivery stations allow servicing specific urban markets and neighbourhoods. They are the most common facility, with an average size of 11,454 m². Delivery stations have large parking lots where about 20 trucks arrive every night to drop off parcels. These parcels are loaded into hundreds of vans each morning, while hundreds more Amazon Flex drivers who use their private cars arrive in the afternoons to deliver what is left. A typical delivery stations generate more than 1,000 vehicle trips each day (Soper, 2020).

The Pantry/Fresh Food Fulfillment Centers specialize in managing orders for perishable and fresh food products as well as cleaning products. Whole Foods Retail Grocery Delivery Centers act as both supermarkets and distribution centers for the Whole Foods chain and online orders. Prime Now Hubs are local delivery hubs located in densely populated metropolitan areas, dedicated to providing express and premium deliveries. Amazon Prime hubs are small, with an average of 4,087 m2, allowing for high demand items to be delivered within 48 hours (Rodrigue, 2020). Inbound Cross Dock Centers process imported goods near major multimodal hubs. Regional Sortation Centers sort packages for a given region and redistribute them to local links in the supply chain. Air Gateways refer to facilities located near or within airports that handle cargo pallets for air cargo services from or to major distribution centers and pooling centers. These facilities operate based on the hub-and-spoke organizational principle (Rodrigue, 2020).

Amazon logistics facilities in France (Assémat, 2019).

In Europe, Amazon Prime operates in London, Paris, Berlin and Milan, next to a few other cities. In Paris, Amazon opened its first Amazon Prime hub in 2016 in the 18th arrondissement. It is the only facility of its kind in France (Assémat, 2019). The hub, converted from a warehouse from Geodis, is dedicated to deliver to Paris and twenty immediate nearby cities in one or two hour. With its 4,000 m², it stores twenty-six categories and more than 20,000 references of products. It is organised much more like an urban grocery store. As of 2023, Amazon has eight distribution centers and 33 warehouses in France, while the UK and Germany have 22 distribution centers each.

Amazon's impressive logistical system is a reflection of the company's rapid growth over the past few decades. According to Rodrigue's analysis from 2020, Amazon has gone through four distinct phases of growth. In the first phase, which started in 1995, Amazon entered the niche market of e-commerce (1) when the internet economy was still in its infancy. During this time, the company had limited distribution centers and only offered digital products, books mostly. The second phase, which began in the mid-2000s, marked a shift in Amazon's business strategy. The company rapidly diversified its product offerings to include electronics, toys, cosmetics, and clothing (2). During this time, Amazon expanded its logistics system to become a dominant e-commerce platform. This expansion included an increase in the number of distribution centers and the opening of the first Inbound Cross Dock for imported goods. Starting in 2010, Amazon implemented an aggressive growth strategy in response to the rapidly growing demand for online shopping in the US. To achieve this, the company opened a large number of distribution centers throughout the country and gradually specialized its warehouses with the opening of Sortation Centers, Delivery Stations, and the first local hubs for the Prime Now premium service (3). Finally, since 2016, Amazon has made three major changes to its logistics system. These include a change of scale with the opening of a large number of warehouses, particularly large distribution centers, making Amazon the dominant player in the US e-commerce sector. Amazon also increased the specialization of its warehouses and implemented a strategy of vertical integration (4), giving the company greater control over the entire distribution and transport chain and reducing its dependence on third-party carriers like UPS and FedEx. Amazon delivers about 67% of its parcels in 2020 and aims to increase that share to 85% (Soper, 2020).

Annual footprint added in Amazon logistics facilities (Rodrigue, 2020).

According to Schorung and Lecourt (2021), Amazon has been using various strategies to expand its logistics system, such as clustering warehouses around transportation hubs and creating a dense network of warehouses in urban areas. These strategies help Amazon reach a broader market, reduce processing and delivery times, and achieve economies of density. The growth of e-commerce has led to a dual logistics real estate market, with large peri-urban or even exurbanized warehouses that structure logistics chains on an international, national and regional scale (Heitz et al., 2017), and smaller urban warehouses designed to serve metropolitan areas and the last mile delivery chain. In this last mile chain, new logistics spaces are built to support the development of new market segments, in particular "instantaneous deliveries" (Dablanc et al., 2017).

However, the multiplication of warehouses in peri-urban spaces and more broadly in lowdensity spaces, known as logistics sprawl (Giuliano et al., 2013; Dablanc et al., 2018), has raised concerns about the environmental impact, land use, and urban planning. Schorung and Lecourt (2021) found that Amazon's logistics sprawl is contributing to the trend, with large distribution warehouses located in suburban areas and an increasingly dense network of warehouses, which increases the company's land and property footprint far from urban centers. Despite efforts to renew interest in central and peri-urban areas, the logistics sprawl continues to expand, creating a contradictory process that increases the urban footprint of the logistics sector. This raises regulatory and management issues in terms of urban planning, land use, real estate, and environmental concerns.

The logistics sprawl to which Amazon contributes can be explained firstly by a change of scale in Amazon's level of activity (explosion of e-commerce and strengthening of this trend during the Covid-19 crisis (Dablanc, 2019), Amazon's dominant position on the US market) and secondly, by the overall evolution of the global supply chain (Hesse, 2008). To meet the needs of logistics operations, Amazon's real estate strategies align with global trends in logistics real estate, such as the need for mutability, automation, space, and modern equipment. Additionally, Amazon treats logistics buildings as financial and real estate assets, and vertically integrates by directly controlling multiple links in the supply chain to reduce dependency on third-party actors. These strategies generate economies of scale and density and take advantage of the dual logistics real estate market.

Amazon's warehouse location strategies are part of a regionalized logistics approach that concentrates large warehouses on the outskirts of metropolitan areas, deploys a fine network of urban logistics spaces, and emphasizes accessibility and location near transport infrastructures. However, these regionalized strategies reveal differentiated systems that take into account territorial arrangements, socio-economic and urban dynamics. The case studies of Chicago, Los Angeles, and the southern part of the Northeast region all show different forms of spatial organization (Schorung and Lecourt, 2021). Chicago follows a classic model of distinct radio-concentric areas, Los Angeles has a polycentric logistics system reflecting the polycentric organization of the metropolitan area, and the southern part of the Northeast region shows a new form of spatial organization that is linear, following the long urban and infrastructure corridor that structures the megalopolis.

In addition to the environmental and urban planning issues, Amazon's logistics sprawl also plays a role in perpetuating social inequalities. Waddell (2021) has conducted an investigation into Amazon’s USA delivery network in 2021. As shown in the figures below, the investigation revealed that most of Amazon’s warehouses are situated in neighborhoods with a disproportionately high number of people of color, and that 57% of Amazon warehouses are located in low-income neighborhoods. Conversely, Whole Foods and other Amazon retail stores tend to be located in wealthier, whiter neighborhoods. The investigation also highlighted that warehouse operators are not generally held accountable for air pollution from the trucks and vans they attract, and that existing air quality monitoring networks are too spread out to pick up local emissions that can affect neighbors’ health. Community activists are calling on local, state, and federal officials to step in and regulate pollution from warehouse-related traffic, and to take into consideration an area’s existing environmental hazards before allowing new warehouses to open there.


References

 

Assémat, A. (2019). Toulouse. De la commande à la livraison, voici comment les colis Amazon arrivent chez vous. Actu Toulouse. https://actu.fr/occitanie/toulouse_31555/toulouse-commande-livraison-voici-comment-colis-amazon-arrivent-chez-vous_29201940.html

Dablanc, L., Savy, M., Veltz, P., Culoz, A., Vincent, M., (2017). Des marchandises dans la ville, un enjeu social, environnemental et économique majeur. Rapport Terra Nova. 113p.

Dablanc, L., Rouhier, J., Lazarevic, N., Klauenberg, J., Liu, Z., Koning, M., Kelli de Oliveira, L., Combes, F., Coulombel, N., Gardrat, N., Blanquart, C., Heitz, A., Seidel, S., (2018). CITYLAB Deliverable 2.1, Observatory of Strategic Developments Impacting Urban Logistics (2018 version), Commission Européenne, 242p.

Dablanc, L., (2019). E-commerce trends and implications for urban logistics. Chapter 8 in Browne, M., Behrends, S., Woxenius, J., Giuliano, G., Holguin-Veras, J. in Urban Logistics. Management, Policy and Innovation in a Rapidly Changing Environment. Kogan Page, London, pp. 167-195.

Giuliano, G., O’Brien, T., Dablanc, L., Holliday, K., (2013). NCFRP Project 36(05) Synthesis of Freight Research in Urban Transportation Planning, Washington D.C.: National Cooperative Freight Research Program.

Heitz, A., Launay, P., & Beziat, A., (2017). Rethinking Data Collection on Logistics Facilities: New Approach for Measuring the Location of Warehouses and Terminals in Metropolitan Areas. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2609.

Hesse, M., (2008) The City as terminal. Logistics and Freight Distribution in an Urban Context. Ashgate publishing.

Rodrigue, J. P. (2020). The distribution network of Amazon and the footprint of freight digitalization. Journal of Transport Geography, 88.

Schorung, M., Lecourt, T. (2021). Analyse des logiques spatiales des entrepôts Amazon suivant une approche multiscalaire et temporelle. Pour une géographie du système logistique d’Amazon aux États-Unis. [Rapport de recherche] Université Gustave Eiffel. https://hal-lara.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-03489397/

Soper, S. (2020, September 16). Amazon Plans to Put 1,000 Warehouses in Neighborhoods. Bloomberg Quint. https://www.bloombergquint.com/business/amazon-plans-to-put-1-000-warehouses-in-neighborhoods

Waddell, K. (2021). When Amazon Expands, These Communities Pay the Price. Consumer Reports. https://www.consumerreports.org/corporate-accountability/when-amazon-expands-these-communities-pay-the-price-a2554249208/